Husbandry
[View/Download PDF]
Ambali A (1997) The Relationship
Between Domestication and Genetic Diversity of Oreochromis Species in Malawi:
Oreochromis shiranus shiranus (Boulener)
and Oreochromis shiranus chilwae (Trewavas).
Dissertation Abstracts International Part B: Science and Engineering.
58(4):1655
NAL Call No. Film S-1806
The fish species domesticated in most African aquaculture activities have not
been genetically identified and characterized; and the distribution of their
genetic diversity is not known. As a result there is continuous mixing of otherwise
genetically differentiated strains leading to loss of between-population genetic
variation. In this study, microsatellite DNA markers for tilapia were developed
to analyze genetic diversity of wild and domesticated populations of O. shiranus species in Malawi. The primers
developed with O. shiranus DNA amplified
microsatellites in other species of the tilapiine fishes. Genetic relationships
among populations of O. shiranus in
Malawi were determined and it was observed that the populations in Lakes Chilwa
and Chiuta belonged to O. shiranus
chilwae while the population in Lake
Malombe belonged to O. shiranus shiranus.
Measures of genetic diversity declined in the domesticated populations compared
to wild populations. The loss of diversity was correlated with the time elapsed
since the founding of farm stock and population genetic differentiation was
also strongly influenced by the pattern of known exchange of germplasm among
farms. Social factors, as measured by transfer proximity, are the key determinants
of genetic distance, not geographic distance. Genetic diversity in the reservoir
populations declined with increase in predator populations which were stocked
either artificially to control tilapia populations, or naturally through streams.
Uncontrolled transfer of germplasm between reservoirs resulted in genetic contamination
of the populations. Socio- economic analysis of small scale farms in Malawi
showed that growout operations were economically viable primarily because pond
inputs comprised recycled on- farm and household waste. The predominance of
integrated crop/livestock/fish farming system was a favorable indicator of the
possibility of involving farmers in community-based aquaculture biodiversity
conservation programs at farm level. The programs would benefit from the knowledge
and experience farmers had already acquired in conserving indigenous breeds
of livestock and crops.
Descriptors: phylogenetics, fish culture, freshwater aquaculture,
genetics, biopolymorphism, Oreochromis
shiranus chilwae, Oreochromis shiranus
shiranus, Africa
ASFA; Copyright © 2003, FAO
Ambali AJD (1998) Domestication
selection of indigenous tilapia species for aquaculture in the Malawian aquaculture
industry. African Fishes and Fisheries Diversity and Utilisation. Poissons
et Peches Africains Diversite et Utilisation. p. 190
Domestication selection and testing of aquaculture species has been based
mainly on growth rate of the species and its ability to breed in culture systems.
There is limited effort to explore the genotype-environmental interaction since
most of the research is centralised in few government stations. In this study
it has been observed that most domesticated populations have been established
from small effective populations to the effect that the genetic diversity of
the populations has been lost, for instance in Malawi wild populations of O.
shiranus spp. have higher mean microsatellite DNA allele number than domesticated
populations, 12.0 ± 4.2 and 3.5 ± 1.0, respectively. Findings in this research
programme suggest that a genetic species selection and testing procedure for
indigenous tilapias based on collimation, scale morphology and brookstock management
enriches the already existing domestication protocols which mainly screen for
performance of species subjected to various feeding and water quality regimes,
and preserves genetic diversity in cultured populations.
Descriptors: aquaculture development, endemic species, aquaculture,
fish culture, domestic species, Oreochromis shiranus, Malawi
ASFA; Copyright © 2003, FAO
Ambali AJD (1997) Genetic considerations
in the domestication of indigenous species for aquaculture: Theory and practice.
Report of the Technical Consultation on Species for Small Reservoir
Fisheries and Aquaculture in
Domesticated stocks have been subjected to processes of evolution as humans
impose selection pressures on crops and animals in order to adapt to the environmental
conditions and human preferences. Aquaculture is relatively young and most cultured
fish species are still close to their wild counterparts. Most South African
countries have rich genetic resources of fishes in the natural waters. Genetic
characterization is an essential component of the screening package for the
candidate indigenous species for aquaculture in order to determine the amount
of genetic variation that exists and identify the various strains of a particular
species. Most of the domestication programmes for fish in
Descriptors: fish culture, endemic species, genetics, hybridization,
aquaculture development,
ASFA
Ambali AJD, Doyle RW, Cook DI (1999)
Genetic changes in Oreochromis shiranus
(Trewavas) associated with the early stages of national aquaculture development
in Malawi. Aquaculture Research. 30(8):579-588
NAL Call No. SH1 F8
A study was carried out to investigate the genetic
diversity during domestication of Oreochromis
shiranus (Trewavas) and to see if it could be associated with events in
the known history of aquaculture development in
Descriptors: man-induced effects, aquaculture techniques,
brood stocks, fish culture, population genetics, aquaculture development, microsatellites,
genetic diversity, Malawi, Oreochromis
shiranus, Oreochromis mossambicus
ASFA; Copyright © 2003, FAO
Brummett RE (no date given) Research
on improved germplasm for aquaculture at the ICLARM Regional Resarch Center
for Africa and West Asia and a note on the domestication of Heterotis niloticus. Biodiversity and Sustainable Use of Fish
in the Coastal Zone. ICLARM Conference Proceedings 63:56-58
This paper highlights the ICLARM's genetic research programme at the Regional
Research Centre for Africa and West Asia in Abbassa, Egypt which began in 1998,
and the developments of this programme. Under this programme populations of
the species Oreachromis niloticus,
O. aureus, Sarotherodon galilaeus and Tilapia
zillii were characterized in terms of growth, yield and food conversion
efficiency. Besides, the objectives of the new collaborative project entitled
“Genetic Enhancement of Tropical Aquaculture species by Combined Selection Marker-Assisted
Selection and Quantitative Trail Loci (QTL) Mapping” are briefed. This project
is proposed to have four phases (1) measuring the heritability and genetic correlations
for growth, (2) gene mapping of the QTL for these straits, (3) development of
selection indices and (4) evaluation of selection. Other activities of ICLARM
lake seeking funding for a network that would bring together the main research
centres working on Heterotis niloticus to coordinate rationalize and share funding.
Descriptors: marine fish, fish culture, aquaculture techniques,
genetics, heterotis niloticus, ASE, Africa, research programmes, domestication,
biodiversity, germplasm
ASFA; Copyright © 2003, FAO
Chiyokubo T, Shikano T, Nakajima
M, Fujio Y (1998) Genetic features of salinity tolerance in wild and domestic
guppies (Poecilia reticulata).
Aquaculture. 167(3-4):339-348
NAL Call No. SH1 A6
To elucidate the genetic features of salinity tolerance
in wild and domestic guppies, Poecilia
reticulata, the present study examined the salinity tolerance in four wild
populations and 13 domestic strains. Salinity tolerance was measured as survival
time after transfer from fresh water to 35 ppt seawater. In the wild guppies,
all four of the wild populations showed significantly higher salinity tolerance
than the 13 domestic strains. After domestication of the wild guppies, their
salinity tolerance significantly decreased with reductions in salinity tolerant
individuals, suggesting inbreeding depression. In the domestic guppies, on the
other hand, strain differences were observed during both 1993 and 1997. A significant
positive correlation between those in 1993 and 1997 suggests that the genetic
constitutions for salinity tolerance have stabilized in each strain as a consequence
of long-term maintenance. F1 hybrids between the domestic strains
showed significantly higher salinity tolerance with many salinity tolerant individuals
which were not observed in their parental strains, thus indicating a heterotic
effect. The salinity tolerance in the F1 hybrids reached the same
level as that in the wild populations. Salinity tolerance significantly decreased
with reductions in the salinity tolerant individuals in the F2.The
results of the domestications and the cross experiments suggested that the significant
difference in salinity tolerance between the wild and the domestic guppies was
caused by heterosis and inbreeding depression.
Descriptors: freshwater fish, hybrids, genetics, natural
populations, salinity tolerance, fish culture, population genetics, hybrid culture,
inbreeding depression, population studies, Poecilia reticulata, domestication, inbreeding, heterosis, guppy,
millions fish, rainbowfish
ASFA; Copyright © 2003, FAO
Fang Yongqiang, Weng Youzhu, Yang
Yao, Chen Lan (1998) Introductive domestication and culture of turbot in
Xiamen. Journal of Oceanography in Taiwan Strait/Taiwan Haixia. Xiamen. 20(3):356-362
The paper reported the experiment on introductive domestication and culture
of two batches of turbot which were from Weihai, Shandong Province in 1997 and
1999 respectively, with whole length about 3 cm to 5 cm. The two batches fry
were cultured indoors. The experimental results indicated that turbot had a
fast growth speed, and the average body weight in eleven-month-old turbot can
reach to 797 g (smallest: 350 g, largest: 1,250 g), and turbot can safely spend
summer indoors. The experiment also found that Ziqi may be as a growth promote
for turbot. In addition, the turbot fry with whole length about 6 cm to 10 cm
and body weight 10-30 g were cultured for five months in the net cages of seawater,
the average body weight can reach to about 400 g. these results will provide
scientific base for the turbot culture in factories and net cages.
Descriptors: fish culture, domestication, introduced species,
tests, disease control, Scophthalmus maximus
ASFA; Copyright © 2003, FAO
Fernoe A, Jaervi T (1998) Domestication
genetically alters the anti-predator behaviour of anadromous brown trout (Salmo trutta) - a dummy predator experiment.
Nordic Journal of Freshwater Research. 74:95-100
NAL Call No. SH287.N6
Domesticated, anadromous brown trout juveniles have been reported to be more
prone to take risks in order to obtain food than juveniles from a wild strain.
This study looked at changes in the actual response to an attacking predator
of juvenile sea trout due to domestication. The progeny of wild and sea-ranched
sea trout were reared in hatcheries under identical conditions for one year.
When exposed to a model predator, domesticated juveniles were more likely to
swim or sink to the bottom and to keep still (freeze) than wild juveniles, which
more often escaped by panic swimming. No difference was found in escape distance.
The results support the view that the hatchery environment selects for risk-taking
individuals.
Descriptors: culture effects, cultured organisms, natural
populations, protective behaviour, predation, genetics, predator prey interactions,
hatcheries, fish culture, domestication, Salmo trutta, brown trout
ASFA; Copyright © 2003, FAO
Gadagkar SR (1998) Social Behaviour
and Growth Rate Variation in Cultivated Tilapia (Oreochromis niloticus). Dissertation Abstracts International
Part B: Science and Engineering. 59(2):no
page numbers given
NAL Call No. Film S-1806
This study was undertaken to understand the behavioural causes of growth
variation in cultivated fish and to study the genetics of agonistic behaviour
vis-a-vis growth rate. The fish studied was a laboratory population of the
Descriptors: social behaviour, aggressive behaviour, domestication,
fish culture, Oreochromis niloticus
ASFA; Copyright © 2003, FAO
Gjedrem T (2000) Genetic improvement
of cold-water fish species. Aquaculture Research. 31(1):25-33
NAL Call No. SH1 F8
Carnivorous fish are two to three times as efficient as pigs and broilers in
converting energy and protein to edible food for humans. As the domestication
of fish continues, they will become more and more efficient and competitive
with these industries. In the future, this will be very important, as more efficient
utilization of available food resources is required to supply the growing human
population with enough food. Today, about 1% of aquaculture production is based
on genetically improved fish and shellfish. For salmonid fishes, we have the
necessary knowledge to establish efficient breeding programmes. Large genetic
variation has been associated with important economic traits. For growth rate,
heritability ranges from 0.2 to 0.3, with a coefficient of variation of 20-30%.
This implies that it is possible to obtain large responses from selection for
growth rate. In several large-scale experiments and in breeding programmes,
10-15% genetic change has been obtained per generation, which is much higher
than that reported for other farm animals. In Norway, extensive breeding experiments
with Atlantic salmon and rainbow trout were started in 1971. For the first two
generations of selection, the breeding goal was growth rate. Age at sexual maturation
(measured as frequency of grilse) was then included. From the fifth generation,
disease resistance (measured by challenge test for furunculosis and the virus
ISA) and meat quality (measured as fat percentage, fat distribution and flesh
colour) were included. Today, Norsk Lakseavl AS (Norwegian Salmon Breeding Company
Ltd) or NLA runs the National Breeding Programme and has two breeding stations
where 400 full-sib and half-sib families of Atlantic salmon are tested in each
of four year classes. For rainbow trout, the number of families totals 120 in
each of three year classes. In 1997, the Norwegian production was 310 000 tons
of Atlantic salmon and 33 000 tons of rainbow trout. At present, about 65% of
the salmon and trout produced in Norway use genetically improved fish from NLA
and multipliers. The cost-benefit ratio for the National Breeding Programme
in Norway is estimated to be 1:15.
Descriptors: fish culture, selective breeding, growth curves,
biological age, disease resistance, body conditions, chemical composition, sexual
maturity, aquaculture techniques, yield, aquaculture, breeding, heritability,
genetic diversity, Salmo salar, Oncorhynchus
mykiss, Salmonidae, Norway, rainbow trout, Atlantic salmon, salmonids
ASFA; Copyright © 2003, FAO
Harada Y, Yokota M, Iizuka M (1998)
Genetic risk of domestication in artificial fish stocking and its possible
reduction. Researches on Population Ecology. 40(3):311-324
NAL Call No. 420 K99
Genetic hazards associated with the stocking of fish juveniles produced in hatcheries
were studied with simple mathematical models. Domestication is the process of
acquiring a genetic characteristics that are advantageous in a hatchery environment
but that are disadvantageous in a natural environment due to the selection pressure
in the hatchery differing from that in the natural environment. Conditions for
the propagation of mutants enhancing domestication were obtained for a variety
of stocking strategies specified by parameters related to hatchery productivity
and kind of brood stock used. By using this, the possibility of reducing the
risk of domestication was studied. As a means of reducing the risk, selective
use of wild-born individuals for brood stock was considered. The effectiveness
of this was analyzed for both the cases where all brood stock is collected from
the wild, and the male brood stock is collected from the wild and the female
brood stock is born and reared in a hatchery. We also estimate how much hatchery
release can be increased without increasing the risk by employing these means.
It is concluded that the use of only male brood stock from the wild is not very
effective in reducing the risk of domestication. Further, it is concluded that
selective use of the wild-born individuals of both sexes for brood stock is
highly desirable if the contribution of released individuals to the natural
reproduction is high. In other words, substantial increase of hatchery release
may be possible while keeping risk at a level comparable to that under moderate
hatchery release, if it is accompanied by the selective use of wild-born individuals
for brood stock.
Descriptors: domestication, genetic factors, risks, stocking,
wildlife management, brood stocks, genetics, hatcheries, stocking (organisms),
fish culture, Pisces
ASFA; Copyright © 2003, FAO
Hassin S, de Monbrison D, Hanin Y,
Elizur A, Zohar Y, Popper DM (1997) Domestication of the white grouper, Epinephelus aeneus 1. Growth and reproduction.
Aquaculture 156(3-4):309-320
NAL Call No. SH1 A6
The growth and reproductive biology of the white grouper,
Epinephelus aeneus, were studied in
captive fish to determine its potential for aquaculture. About 250 fish were
captured by fishermen along the Mediterranean coast and maintained in 16 m3
concrete tanks supplied with sea water in a flow-through system. The captive
fish fed readily on dry pellets supplemented with chopped frozen fish and gained
an average of 3.3 g/day during the initial growth phase (0.5-1.5 kg), and 11.3
g/day during the secondary growth phase (1.5-3.0 kg). Using ovarian biopsies,
the sexual development of 17 females was closely monitored for 3 years, and
for 1 year in an additional 47 females. In adult females held in captivity,
the oocytes reached the final stages of vitellogenesis, however, final oocyte
maturation, ovulation and spawning did not occur. Sustained release of [d-Ala6,Pro9NEt]-GnRH
from implanted devices was highly effective in inducing ovulation, but did not
result in natural spawning. Repeated implantations resulted in 2-3 ovulations
per reproductive season, which lasted from April through September. The ovulated
females were manually stripped and the eggs were artificially fertilized, resulting
in millions of fertilized eggs and larvae. The average fecundity per female
was 242 343 eggs (kg BW)-1yr-1. In some of the young females, early vitellogenesis
did not lead to the final stages of vitellogenesis. Instead, the vitellogenic
oocytes underwent rapid atresia. Monitoring individual fish demonstrated that
E. aeneus is a protogynous hermaphrodite, changing sex from female to male,
confirming reports by other authors. Sex inversion occurred both spontaneously
and after implantation with 17 alpha -methyltestosterone. The rapid growth rates
and the potential for induced spawning in captivity make the white grouper an
excellent candidate for mariculture.
Descriptors: commercial species, fish culture, marine fish,
aquaculture development, induced breeding, fish eggs, Epinephelus aeneus, white grouper
ASFA; Copyright © 2003, FAO
Hollebecq MG, Haffray P (1999) Genetic
improvements. Carp: Biology and Culture. pp. 101-123.
NAL Call No. SH167 C3 C3713 1999
Chapter 4 focuses on genetic improvement: domestication;
starins identification and management, performance assessment, breeding and
hybridizations; selection methods; sex control and polyploidization; molecular
genetics and transgenesis
Descriptors: fish culture, population genetics, selective
breeding, brood stocks, Cyprinidae, Cyprinus
carpio
ASFA; Copyright © 2003, FAO
Jacobs JM, Lindell S, Van Heukelem
W, Hallerman EM, Harrell RM (1999) Strain evaluation of striped bass (Morone saxatilis) under controlled conditions.
Aquaculture. 173(1-4):171-177
NAL Call No. SH1 A6
Commercial hybrid striped bass production is one of the
fastest growing segments of the US aquaculture industry. However, broodstock
domestication and selective breeding on a production scale have yet to be exploited.
We reared progeny from five wild striped bass (Morone saxatilis) populations representing
New York to Florida at two facilities (Horn Point Laboratory (HPL), Cambridge,
MD and AquaFuture (AFI), Turners Falls, MA). Some 19 families were grown for
approximately 150 days in recirculating aquaculture systems and evaluated for
differences in growth rate. Maryland and Florida Blackwater populations exhibited
higher growth rates than the South Carolina and New York strains (P<.05)
with Florida St. John's fish showing intermediate growth. All strains grew significantly
faster at AFI than HPL (P=0.001) with absolute growth rate (g/day) strongly
correlated at the two facilities (SCC=0.823, P=0.0001).
Descriptors: fish culture, brood stocks, hybrid culture,
phylogenetics, recirculating systems, Morone
saxatilis, rockfish
ASFA; Copyright © 2003, FAO
Lal KK, Ponniah AG (2000) Reproductive
biology estimators for conservation and culture of fish. Endemic
Fish Diversity of
Captive breeding is an essential prerequisite for successful domestication of
a new species; it also plays a significant role in conservation of wild germplasm
through maintaining live gene banks of captive brood stocks and for repopulating
depleted natural habitats. Different reproductive biology estimators are useful
for predicting reproductive success as well as in developing manipulative techniques
for both culture and conservation. An examination is made of various estimators
which can be used individually and collectively depending upon the end objective.
The following parameters are discussed: reproductive strategy; sexual dimorphism;
sex ratio; age and size at first maturity; potential fecundity; gonad features;
gonadosomatic index; and, oocyte diameter.
Descriptors: freshwater fish, fish culture, reproduction,
resource conservation, sexual maturity, spawning populations,
ASFA; Copyright © 2003, FAO
Lepage O, Oeverli Oe, Petersson E,
Jaervi T, Winberg S (2000) Differential stress coping in wild and domesticated
sea trout. Brain, Behavior and Evolution. 56(5):259-268
Offspring of wild and sea-ranched (domesticated) sea trout (Salmo trutta) originating from the same
river, were reared under identical hatchery conditions from the time of fertilization.
At one year of age individual fish were exposed to two standardized stressors;
transfer to a novel environment, with or without a simultaneous predator exposure.
Blood plasma concentrations of glucose and cortisol were analyzed along with
brain levels of dopamine (DA), 3,4-hydroxyphenylacetic acid (DOPAC, a major
DA metabolite), serotonin (5-hydroxytryptamine, 5-HT), and 5-hydroxyindoleacetic
acid (5 HIAA, a major 5-HT metabolite). Transfer to a novel environment, alone
as well as in combination with predator exposure, resulted in elevated plasma
concentrations of glucose and cortisol. Moreover, exposure to these stressors
resulted in elevated brain levels of 5-HT and 5-HIAA, as well as elevated brain
5-HIAA/5-HT and DOPAC/DA ratios. Wild trout displayed significantly higher post
stress plasma glucose levels than domesticated fish. Similarly, following stress,
brain 5-HIAA/5-HT and DOPAC/DA ratios were significantly higher in wild than
in domesticated fish. These differences were not caused by differences in brain
levels of 5-HIAA and DOPAC, but instead by differences in brain 5-HT and DA
concentrations. These results suggest that domestication results in attenuated
stress responses in trout, and that alterations in brain monoamine neurotransmission
are part of this effect.
Descriptors: stress, adaptability, novelty, predation, glucose,
hydrocortisone, domestication, neurotransmitters, biological stress, fish physiology,
stocking (organisms), cultured organisms, natural populations, Salmo
trutta, brown trout
ASFA; Copyright © 2003, FAO
Liao IC (2000) The state of finfish
diversification in Asian aquaculture. Recent Advances in Mediterranean Aquaculture Finfish Species Diversification.
Proceedings of the Seminar of the CIHEAM Network on Technology of Aquaculture
in the Mediterranean (TECAM), jointly organized by CIHEAM and FAO, Zaragoza
(Spain), 24-28 May 1999. Cahiers Options Mediterraneennes. Zaragoza
47:109-125
Aquaculture in
Descriptors: aquaculture, aquaculture development, induced
breeding, domestication, introduced species, check lists, hybridization, fish
culture, species diversity, Taiwan
ASFA; Copyright © 2003, FAO
Mamontov YuP, Rekubratskiy AV (1998)
Carp domestication and breeding. Rybovodstvo i Rybolovstvo. Moscow.
3-4:31-33 (In Russian with English summary)
The history of domestication of wild carp as an ancestor of carps (Cyprinidae) in Asia and Europe as well
as their morphological differences are considered. The next signs of domestication
are discussed: 1) specimens have economical value; 2) the breeding is under
man's control; 3) carps behaviour differs from its wild ancestor; 4) some hatchery-bred
fish are not able to survive without man's help.
Descriptors: fish culture, breeding ponds, domestication,
I, China, People's Rep., Japan, Europe, Inland Waters, Israel
ASFA; Copyright © 2003, FAO
Sola L, De Innocentis S, Rossi AR,
Crosetti D, Scardi M, Boglione C, Cataudella S (1998) Genetic variability
and fingerling quality in wild and reared stocks of European sea bass, Dicentrarchus
labrax. Genetics and breeding of Mediterranean aquaculture
species. Cahiers Options Mediterraneennes. Zaragoza. 34:273-280
The development of sustainable aquaculture models requires an increasing knowledge
of hatchery production practices. This preliminary study has aimed at investigating
the domestication process in the European sea bass, Dicentrarchus labrax. Genetic variability
and frequencies of anatomical abnormalities were inspected in 5 hatcheries and
in one sample of wild sea bass juveniles. Gene-enzyme analysis (carried out
through starch gel electrophoresis on about 300 individuals) revealed low genetic
distances among groups, and allelic and genotypic frequency shifts in the hatchery
groups when compared to the wild one. The analysis of differences in meristic
counts and physical anomaly types and frequencies (evaluated on more than 430
juveniles) revealed a wide morphological variation among the hatchery groups
and also between these and the wild group, with some hatchery-specific trends.
Descriptors: fish culture, fingerlings, genetics, biopolymorphism,
stocks, Dicentrarchus labrax, MED,
Europe, comparative studies
ASFA; Copyright © 2003, FAO
An Illustration of Domestication Selection in a Hatchery
Program of Steelhead
http://www-heb.pac.dfo-mpo.gc.ca/congress/2002/Hatchery/Reisenbichler.pdf
Analyzing Genetic and Behavioral Changes During Salmonid
Domestication
http://www.cbfwa.org/fwprogram/ResultProposal.cfm?PPID=WP2000000020045
Aspects of Animal Welfare and Aquaculture - A Compendium of Selected Literature by
Richard D. Moccia and Kristopher P. Chandroo; Aquaculture Centre,
http://www.aps.uoguelph.ca/~aquacentre/aec/publications/welfare-bib.html
Devlin
RH Biagi CA, Yesaki TY,
DOI: 10.1038/35057314
Akse L, Midling K (2000) Slaughtering
of Atlantic Halibut (Hippoglossus hippoglossus):
Effect on Quality and Storing Capacity. In: Farmed Fish Quality. Eds:
NAL Call
No. SH151 F37 2001
Through 15 years of intensive biological research, Atlantic halibut is now established
as the most promising species in Norwegian marine aquaculture. Annual production
is still small, but is expected to grow rapidly. However, knowledge on muscle
quality and what factors affect the product in this species are scarce. In this
project a number of experiments were conducted on farmed Atlantic halibut. Except
for the initial pH, we were not able to detect major differences in post-mortem
quality between the stressed and not stressed halibut. Compared to several other
species, Atlantic halibut has exceptional storing capacity both in sensory,
chemical and microbiological terms. In this experiment, this is demonstrated
by almost no development in pH, TVBN and viable bacteria values until after
day 21. Farmed Atlantic halibut is likely to be accepted in the market as fresh
fish at least one week longer than other white fish species (e.g. cod). CO2
performed poorly as an anaesthetic and resulted in rapid onset of rigor mortis
and high hardness values. Eugenol postponed onset of rigor mortis by 14 to 16
hours compared to CO2 and gave a significantly lower measured hardness.
Killing by a blow to the head resulted in increased variation in onset time
and development of rigor mortis. Small differences were found in haem iron muscle
residues among the groups, but halibut killed by a blow to the head were significantly
better bled than fish anaesthetized with CO2.
Descriptors: fish culture,
seafood, quality control, slaughter, fish storage, storage life, Hippoglossus hippoglossus, Atlantic halibut
ASFA; Copyright © 2003, FAO
Annonymous. (1997) Welfare of fish at slaughter. Trout News. 24:42-44
The report of a workshop sponsored by the Humane Slaughter
Association and the British Trout Association. The industry view, the veterinary
view, research on slaughter methods, and industry requirements were covered.
Descriptors: fisheries, slaughter,
animal welfare
ASFA; Copyright © 2003, FAO
Bernoth EM, Wormuth HJ (1991) Tierschutzaspekte bei der Toetung von Fischen. [Aspects of animal welfare
in killing fishes.] Bundesgesundheitsblatt. 34(1):8-10 (In German)
Descriptors: fishes, destruction
of animal, slaughtering, animal welfare, animal health, animals, aquatic animals,
aquatic organisms, harvesting, methods,
processing
Bernoth EV (1990) Schaedigung
von Fischen durch Turbinenanlagen. [Fish damage by turbines.] Deutsche
Tieraerztliche Wochenschrift. 97(3):161-164
(In German with English summary)
NAL Call No. 41.8 D482
Descriptors: fishes, lesions,
water power, machinery, animal welfare, animal health, animals, aquatic animals,
aquatic organisms, energy sources, equipment, injurious factors,
natural resources
Bernoth EM von, Wormuth HJ (1990) Tierschutzaspekte bei der Toetung von Fischen. [Animal protection aspects
on killing of fish.] Deutsche Tieraerztliche Wochenschrift. 97(4):154-157 (In German with English summary)
NAL Call No. 41.8 D482
According to the Animal Protection Law (1986) fish are
to be killed by methods which do not cause pain. However, the regulations do
not cover the killing of non-food fish. A questionnaire, conducted among 85
fish scientists, revealed that single fish should be killed by a blow on the
head, and larger numbers by electrical methods or by use of chemicals. Decapitation
was proposed for eels. A regulation from 1936 stipulates the methods for the
slaughtering of food fish. Mechanical or electrical stunning is compulsory except
for eel and flatfish. The questionnaire showed that in general the present legal
regulations are sufficient for the slaughtering of fish with the exception of
eels. The commercially available apparatus for stunning and killing do not always
fulfill the requirements of animal protection, slaughtering technology and safety
for the user. Official testing of these apparatus as well as the evaluation
of new methods - like CO2 -stunning - are necessary in order to prevent
the use of methods which are feasible, but do not fulfill animal welfare, especially
for eel.
Descriptors: fishes, slaughtering,
destruction of animals, animal welfare, animal health, animals, aquatic animals,
aquatic organisms, harvesting, methods, processing, government policy, mortality
causes, commercial species, fishery technology, fish handling, processing fishery
products, slaughter, fish, animal welfare
ASFA;
Copyright © 2003, FAO
Bretzinger C (2001) Einfluss unterschiedlicher Betaeubungsmethoden
auf Stressbelastung und Produktqualitaet bei der Regenbogenforelle (Oncorhynchus
mykiss) [Influence of different pre-slaughter stunning methods on stress
reaction and product quality of rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus
mykiss)]. Muenchen FRG Hieronymus.
189 pp. (In German)
Dissertation. (Dr. vet. med.); Incl. 20 pages refs.
In the present study the stunning of rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) via pulsed direct
current electroshock, carbon dioxide exposition without and with oxygen enrichment
and anaesthesia with the fish anaesthetic AQUI-S in comparison to stunning with
a blow on the head was examined with respect to animal welfare and product quality
of fish as food. The aspect of animal welfare was assessed by determination
of the parameters respiration, aversive reactions, mucus secretion and the time
period until fish enter anaesthesia as well as the blood parameters adrenaline,
noradrenaline and packed cell volume. Product quality was evaluated by registration
of carcass lesions, hemorrhages and fillet colour. All five methods proved to
be effective for anaesthesia of trout. The blow on the head is the preferable
method to stun consumption-sized rainbow trout if only a small number of fish
is to be slaughtered. The electroshock method was not suitable for stunning
larger numbers of trout for a sufficient period of time. Introduction of pure
CO2 gas, respectively CO2 and CO2 into water,
also had to be considered as not suited because the fish showed strong signs
of dyspnoe and aversive reactions until entering anaesthesia for on average
10 min., respectively 12 min. Oxygen enrichment obviously did not reduce the
stress influence on trout. Applying the fish anaesthetic AQUI-S in a dose rate
of 25 ppm enabled to stun rainbow trout for the slaughtering process. During
an average narcosis period of 9 min. no signs of dyspnoe or an aversive reaction
were recorded. Therefore, AQUI-S can be recommended -- without considering food
and drug legislation -- as an alternative method for stunning large amounts
of fish, which fulfills the requirements of animal welfare. The blood parameters
adrenaline and noradrenaline showed significant differences between the stunning
methods. The blow to the head and anaesthesia with AQUI-S gave -- comparable
with each other -- the lowest values for adrenaline and noradrenaline. At the
end of electronarcosis intermediate amounts, after carbon dioxide exposition
and CO2/CO2 narcosis the highest catecholamine concentrations
were measured. The latter indicates a strong stress reaction. The packed cell
volume values were lowest after percussive stunning. For the remaining methods
higher values were determined. Visible alterations regarding the product quality
of the carcasses were registered in trout being stunned by electroshock, which
showed “current marks” and hemorrhages. The results of the colour measurements
did not give hints on negative effects on product quality in dependence of the
stunning method.
Descriptors: slaughter, anaesthetics,
quality assurance, human food Oncorhynchus
mykiss
ASFA; Copyright © 2003, FAO
Coutant, C.C., Whitney, R.R (2000)
Fish behavior in relation to passage
through hydropower turbines: A Review. Transactions of the American Fisheries Society.
129(2):351-380
NAL Call No. 414.9 Am3
We evaluated the literature on fish behavior as it relates
to passage of fish near or through hydropower turbines. Our goal was to foster
compatibility of engineered systems with the normal behavior patterns of fish
species and life stages such that passage into turbines and injury in passage
are minimized. In particular, we focused on aspects of fish behavior that could
be used for computational fluid dynamics (CFD) modeling of fish trajectories
through turbine systems. Salmon smolts approaching dams are generally surface
oriented and follow flow. They can be diverted from turbines by spills or bypasses,
with varying degrees of effectiveness. Smolts typically become disoriented in
dam forebays. Those smolts drawn into turbine intakes orient vertically to the
ceilings but are horizontally distributed more evenly, except as they are affected
by intake specific turbulence and vortices. Smolts often enter intakes while
oriented with their heads upstream, but they may change orientation in the flow
fields of the intake. Nonsalmonids most often enter intakes from the vicinities
of shorelines, and they do so episodically, which suggests accidental capture
of schools (often of juveniles or in cold water) and little behavioral control
during turbine passage. Models of fish trajectories should not assume neutral
buoyancy throughout the time period during which a fish passes through a turbine,
largely because of pressure effects on swim bladders and the resulting compensatory
behavior. Fish use their lateral line system to sense obstacles and to change
their orientation, but this sensory response system may not be effective in
the rapid passage times and complex pressure regimes of turbine systems. The
effects of preexisting stress levels on fish performance in turbine passage
(especially as they affect trajectories) are not known but may be important.
There are practical limits of observation and measurement of fish and flows
in the proximity of turbines that may inhibit the development of much information
that is germane to developing a more fish friendly turbine. We provide recommendations
for CFD modelers of fish passage and for additional research.
Descriptors: literature reviews,
freshwater fish, anadromous species, migratory species, smolts, lateral line,
orientation behaviour, biological stress, avoidance reactions, entrainment,
hydroelectric power plants, rivers, fishways, fishery management, salmon fisheries,
river fisheries, nature conservation, river engineering, reviews, animal welfare,
human impact, hydropower turbines, fish passages, hydroelectric plants, fish
behavior, literature review, salmon, turbines, fish migration, Salmonidae
ASFA; Copyright © 2003, FAO
Drawer K (1987) Die
Praxis der Schlachttierbetaeubung aus der Sicht des Tierschutzes. [Animal welfare
in stunning of slaughter-animals.] Tieraerztliche
Umschau. 42(11):878-885. (In German)
NAL Call No. 41.8
T445
Descriptors: domestic animals,
stunning, animal welfare, animal health, animals, fishing methods, fishing operations,
harvesting, methods, processing, slaughtering, fish welfare
Drawer K (1987) Das
Schlachten von Tieren im geaenderten Tierschutzgesetz [Slaughtering of animals
in the new animals welfare act]. Deutsche
Tieraerztliche Wochenschrift. 94(2):106-107.
(In German)
NAL Call No. 41.8 D482
Descriptors: domestic animals,
slaughtering, animal welfare, laws, stunning, animal health, animals, fishing
methods, fishing operations, harvesting, legislation, methods, processing, slaughtering
Drosse H (1994)
Die “Lebendhaelterung” gefangener Fische im Setzkescher. [Fish farming landing
nets.] Rundschau fuer Fleischhygiene
und Lebensmittelueberwachung. 46(9):207-209. ISSN: 0178-2010
Descriptors: game fishes, angling, animal welfare, fish cages,
legislation, fishing rights, aquaculture equipment, equipment, fishing methods,
legal rights
Grandin T (1985) Cardiac
arrest stunning of livestock and poultry.
Eds: Fox MW, Mickley LD. Advances in Animal Welfare Science. Martinus
Nijhoff,
NAL Call No. HV4701
A34
Descriptors: livestock, poultry,
stunning, heart, anatomy, animal anatomy, animals, birds, body parts, cardiovascular
system, domestic animals, domesticated birds, fishing methods, fishing operations,
harvesting, methods, processing, slaughtering, vertebrates
Gregory NG (1998) Animal
Welfare and Meat Science. CAB International.Wallingford, OX10 8DE, UK.
298 pp.
NAL Call No. HV4731 G74 1998
It is recognised that careful and humane treatment of
slaughter animals at the abattoir influences the quality of their meat, apart
from humane considerations, and supporting evidence is assembled here. Correct
slaughter procedure and appropriate abattoir installations are dealt with. There
are separate chapters on cattle, sheep, pigs, poultry and fish, to deal with
special requirements for each species.
Descriptors: slaughter, livestock, fish, animal welfare, meat quality
Copyright © 2003, CAB International.
Gregory NG (1996) Welfare and hygiene during preslaughter handling.
Meat Science 43 (suppl.):S35-S46
Massey University, Palmerston North, NZ.
NAL Call No. TX373.M4
Descriptors: meat quality,
slaughter, animal welfare, stress, abattoirs, carcass quality, damage, food
hygiene, literature reviews, glycogen, muscles, metabolism, handling, fish,
pigs, beef cattle
NAL Call No. 41.8 V641
Descriptors: marine fishes, freshwater fishes, stunning,
slaughter, animal welfare, brain, physiological functions, neurophysiology,
evaluation, anesthesia, animal behavior
Kestin S (1993) Welfare
of fish at harvest. Trout News.
17:28-30
Descriptors: fishes, fish
culture, death, animal welfare, slaughter, Oncorhynchus
mykiss, aquaculture, bony fishes, developmental stages, fish, salmonoidei
Knierim U (1996) Die Tierscutz-Schlachtverordnung. [The animal
welfare regulations at slaughter.] Deutsche Tierarztliche Wochenschrift 103(2):52-54 (In German with English summary)
NAL Call No. 41.8 D482
The animal welfare regulation on the slaughter of animals,
existing only as a draft for the time being, is designed not only to transpose
EC-legislation into national law but also to update and strengthen preconstitutional
national legislation on this matter. For a wide area related to the slaughter
or killing of animals, animal welfare requirements are put in concrete terms.
Among the topics belonging to this area are the theoretical and practical knowledge
of the personnel, the handling of animals before slaughter or killing, stunning,
the control of its efficacy and the permessibility of certain stunning or killing
methods. Not only livestock but also, for example, fur animals and fish are
concerned. In practice it will take some efforts in order to attain compliance
with the provisions of the animal welfare slaughter regulation.
Descriptors: regulations, stunning, poultry, legislation, slaughter,
animal welfare, cattle, pigs, sheep, fishes
Lambooij E, Vis JW, van de Kloosterboer
RJ, Pieterse C (2002) Welfare aspects
of live chilling and freezing of farmed eel (
NAL Call No. SH1A6
The overall objective of the study was to evaluate a
slaughter method of eels, which consisted of chilling until their body temperature
was <5 °C for stunning, and subsequently placing them in cold brine at -18°C
for 15 min for killing. Three distinct experiments and a control were performed.
First, 19 eels with an average live weight of 758 ± 44 g were restrained and
equipped with EEG, ECG electrodes and a temperature sensor inside the body.
Then, they were placed in the ice water. Indices for the induction of unconsciousness
and insensibility were the appearance of theta and delta waves and no response
on pain stimuli, which disappeared at a body temperature of 8.0 ± 2.1°C after
12 ± 5 min in 15 eels. The responses to pain stimuli did not disappear in three
eels. Within a confidence level of 95%, the percentage of eels that was not
effectively stunned during the procedure in ice water of <5°C was at least
5%. The heart rate decreased from 24 ± 10 beats/min (n=14) to 7 ± 4 (n=11) and
became irregular during cooling down. When placed in the brine water of -18°C,
the EEG showed rapid and extreme depolarization of the membranes, which started
after 27 ± 17 seconds (n=18). The ECG showed fluttering of the heart in all
eels. None of the eels recovered after this procedure. For 10 eels with an average
live weight of 128 ± 27 g, it was observed that the body temperature decreased
from 17.1 ± 0.6 to 4.0 ± 0.5°C in the ice water. After 15 min in the brine water
of -16.1 ± 2.2°C, the body temperature decreased to -3.1 ± 2.3°C. Finally, three
groups of 7 eels and 8 single eels were placed in ice water of -0.0 ± 0.1°C.
The observation of unrestrained eels revealed four phases. Animals were (1)
swimming around in the water, (2) attempting to escape from the ice water, (3)
pressing their nose to the wall or corner while showing clonic muscle cramps,
and finally (4) breathing only, while all other muscle activity was totally
suppressed. Afterwards, they were transferred to cold brine at -18°C, and none
of the eels recovered. The eight control eels, which were transferred to water
at 18°C, swam around, except for one that was lying in an S-shape position at
the bottom. After 570 and 605 seconds, two eels tried to escape from the box.
The obtained results showed that the eels, which were transferred from water
at 18°C to ice water, might be stressed, a specific behaviour and an irregular
heart rate were observed. From an animal welfare point of view, it is therefore
not recommended to stun eels by live chilling. Moreover, at least 5% of the
eels will not be stunned at a body temperature of <5°C. Placing eels in brine
water of -18°C is an effective method to kill the eels before slaughter. However,
it cannot be recommended to place conscious eels in cold brine water, because
it takes more than 27 seconds before unconsciousness may be induced.
Descriptors: animal behaviour, animal welfare, body temperature,
chilling, freezing, heart rate, neurology, pain, slaughter, stunning, eels,
Anguilla, Anguillidae, Anguilliformes,
Osteichthyes, fishes, diadromous fishes, aquatic animals, aquatic organisms
Copyright © 2003, CAB International.
Marx H, Brunner B, Weinzierl W, Hoffmann R, Stolle A
(1997) Methoden zur Betaeubung von Suesswasserfischen
: Einfluss auf die Fleischqualitaet und Tierschutzaspekte. [Methods of stunning
freshwater fish: impact on meat quality and aspects of animal welfare.]
Zeitschrift fuer Lebensmittel Untersuchung
und Forschung. 204(4): 282-286 (In German with English summary)
NAL
Call No. TX341 Z45
Taking into account aspects of meat quality and animal
welfare, three methods of stunning fish were compared: a manual technique (blow
on the head, stab in the neck), one using electricity and one using CO2.
The following results were obtained using eel, carp and trout. From the viewpoint
of animal welfare, the effects on the fish were judged. Exitation and mucus
secretion as well as the time taken for the fish to be anaesthetized were recorded.
With manual and electricalstunning, all fish were anaesthetized almost immediately,
while using CO2 it took 3.2 min (trout), 9.2 min (carp) and 109.7
min (eel) on average. After slaughter and after 3 and 8 days of storage on ice,
the fish meat quality parameters, i.e. pH value, water-holding capacity and
rigor mortis, were measured. CO2 stunning gave rise to the lowest
pH values and water-holding capacities.
Rigor mortis in carp and eel advanced the most. Testing of raw and prepared
fish was performed by a panel assessing organoleptic properties. In many cases,
fish anaesthetized manually were ranked to be better than those in the other
groups.
Descriptors: freshwater fishes,
fish, stunning, time, quality, pH, water holding capacity, postmortem changes,
organoleptic properties, animal welfare, eels, carp, trout, animal products,
chemicophysical properties, diadromous fishes, fishery products, fishes, freshwater
fishes, quality
Marx H, Brunner B, Weinzierl W, Hoffmann
R, Stolle A. (1996) Comparative investigations
on different methods for stunning fish with special regard to meat quality parameters. Proceedings of the Conference of IIR Commission
C2, Bordeaux Colloquium Refrigeration and Aquaculture Froid et Aquaculture Colloque de Bordeaux, compte rendu de la reunion de la Commission C2 de l'IIF Paris France
Institut International du Froid. pp. 199-206
NAL Call No. TP490
S34
Taking into account aspects of meat quality and animal
welfare, three methods for stunning fish were compared: manually (blow on the
head, stab in the neck) with electricity and using CO2. The following
results were obtained for eel (n = 72), carp (n = 120) and trout (n = 54). From
the view of animal welfare, the effects on the fish were judged. Excitation
and mucus secretion, as weIl as the period of lime until the fish were in anaesthesia
were recorded. With manual and electrical stunning, aIl fish were anaesthetized
almost immediately, while using CO2, it takes 3.2 min (trout), 9.2
min (carp) and 109.7 min (eel), on average. After slaughter, after three and
eight days of storing the fish on ice, the meat quality parameters, pH value,
water holding capacity and rigor mortis were measured. CO2 stunning
showed the lowest pH-values and water holding capacities; also, rigor mortis
in carp and eel advanced most. Testing of raw and prepared fish was performed
by a sensoric team. In many cases, fish anaesthetized manually were ranked better
than the other groups. The findings indicate that CO2 was not appropriate
for stunning carp and eel. Electrical stunning, with some improvements, could
meet the requirements of meat quality and animal welfare.
Descriptors: processing fishery
products, anaesthesia, slaughter, quality, Oncorhynchus mykiss, Cyprinus carpio, Anguilla anguilla
ASFA; Copyright © 2003, FAO
Muenkner W, Kuhlmann H, Oehlenschlaeger
J (2000) Sensibilitaet von Seefischen
an Bord. Teil 2: Demersale und pelagische
Fischarten aus Schleppnetzfaengen in der Nord und Ostsee. [Investigations on the sensitiveness
of sea water fish on board -- Part 2: Demersal and pelagic fish species of the
North and Baltic Sea.] Inf Fischwirtsch Fischereiforsch. 47(2):97-101 (In German)
The sensitiveness of different demersal and pelagic fish
species of 70 hauls in the North and Baltic Sea in water depths of 60 to 250
m and 15 to 80 m, respectively, amount of catch of 100 to 3500 kg and trawling
times of 0,5 to 6 h on board of the FRV Walther Herwig III was investigated.
Some demersal fish species, e.g. saithe (Pollachius virens), were even still sensitive, when caught at a water
depth of 250 m at a trawling time of 1,5 h. Generally the number of sensitive
fishes was reduced with increasing water depth, amount of catch, trawling time
and following storage of the catch on board. Among demersal fishes the species
without swimbladder and flat fishes were clearly more resistent to mechanical
stress. On the contrary, pelagic fish species were generally less robust. After
trawling times of 2 h no sensitive animals were observed. In some fisheries
there are mixed catches of demersal and pelagic fish species with different
sensitiveness. In commercial fisheries, there is therefore
under animal welfare aspects for the time being, no prospect for an improvement
of the catching and slaughtering procedure on board.
Descriptors: biological stress,
bottom trawls, midwater trawls, total mortality, Pollachius virens, Gadus morhua, Clupea harengus, Melanogrammus aeglefinus,
ANE
ASFA; Copyright © 2003, FAO
Neukirch M (1994) Legal
and animal welfare aspects of the killing of fish. [Uber rechtliche und tierschutzrelevante
Aspekte bei der Totung von Fischen.] Deutsche Tierarztliche Wochenschrift (Germany).
101(8):316-319
NAL Call No. 41.8 D482
The selection of methods for killing fish is determined by the number of fish
to be killed, their utilization and the existing laws. No regulations exist
for killing non-food fish. The methods for killing food-fish, however, are stipulated
in a regulation from 1936. Mechanical or electrical stunning is obligatory except
for flatfish and eel. Single fish should be stunned by a blow on the head, followed
immediately by slaughtering or bleeding to be sure that the fish is really dead.
When larger numbers of fish should be killed for food production only electrical
methods are allowed as alternative. Chemicals can be used for killing non-food
fish, the non-pollutant destruction of dead fish and chemical-contaminated water,
however, has to be guaranteed. The methods are discussed with respect to practicability
and animal welfare.
Descriptors: animal welfare, fisheries,
legislation and jurisprudence,
fishes, physiology, electric stimulation,
Nowak D (1989) Tierschutzrelevante Aspekte bei Halterung,
Verkauf und Totung von Susswasserspeisefischen. [Welfare aspects of the holding,
selling and killing of freshwater fishes for food.] Rundschau fur Fleischhygiene und Lebensmitteluberwachung
41(7):139-140 (In German)
Descriptors: animal welfare, aquaculture, fish farming
Oehlenslager J, Kestin SC, Tejada
M, Sorensen NK, Torrissen OJ, Nesvabda P, Van Rijsingen LCM (1998) Optimisation of harvest procedures of farmed
fish with respect to qualify and welfare. Third European Marine Science and Technology Conference MAST Conference,
Lisbon, 23 27 May 1998: Project Synopses Vol 6: Fisheries and Aquaculture FAIR:
1994 98, Selected Projects from the Research Programme for Agriculture and Fisheries
including Agro Industry, Food Technology, Forestry, Aquaculture and Rural Development
FAIR. Luxembourg
Luxembourg European Commission DG 12 Science, Research and Development. 6:244-245
In the last decade consumers have become
much more aware of product quality. This also includes the production and processing
of animals under humane conditions. The greater awareness has led to an increased
focus by processors on the quality of farmed fish. For some fish species, harvest
conditions, especially slaughter, have been reported to have an adverse affect
on flesh quality. This may result from the effects of stress, for example when
the killing method is not instantaneous, in which case the welfare of the fish
will also be affected. Preliminary results indicate that methods which kill
fish rapidly can result in an improvement in quality and a reduction of stress,
thereby also leading to an improvement in welfare. The objectives of the proposed
study are therefore twofold: (1) the optimisation of the slaughter process of
farmed fish with respect to quality and welfare, and (2) the automation of these
optimum processes. The study will be undertaken on salmon (Salmo
salar), gilt head bream (Sparus aurata)
and eels (Anguilla anguilla). These
three model species have been selected as they differ in their physiology. They
will enable comparisons of species that require well oxygenated water (salmon)
vs. less oxygenated water (eel) and that
live in salt water (gilt head bream) vs. fresh water (eel). The differences
in physiology are likely to be important for instantaneous killing methods and,
when instantaneous killing is not possible, stunning prior to killing. Analytical
and biochemical measurements will be used to assess eating and processing quality
immediately post mortem and during subsequent handling and storage. The welfare
aspects of killing methods will be evaluated by measuring brain activity in
combination with observations of behaviour (using video recordings of fish in
tanks) to determine how quickly death occurs of a state of insensibility is
reached. Based on the results obtained, the automation of the optimum procedures,
including use of folgrade anaesthetics, will be investigated with respect to
compatibility with further processing, textural and sensory analysis. For the
automation of slaughter processes which would be feasible fore use by SMEs,
two SMEs and an association of fish farmers are involved in the project.
Descriptors: harvesting, fishery
products, quality control, fish ponds
ASFA; Copyright © 2003, FAO
Ottera H, Roth B, Torrissen OJ (1999)
Do Killing Methods Affect the Quality
of Atlantic Salmon? Farmed Fish Quality.
(Eds.)
NAL Call No. SH151 F37 2001
The methods used for stunning and killing fish species
in aquaculture have recently received a lot of attention, from an ethical point
of view - does the fish suffer unnecessary pain during the process - and also
from a product quality point of view. These two aspects were the rationale for
the EU-project “Optimization of harvest procedures of farmed fish with respect
to quality and welfare - FAIR CT97-3127 FAQUWEL.” Here we present some of the
preliminary results on product quality of Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar) as affected by killing method. We are evaluating four
methods for killing the salmon: Sedation by COZ, followed by gill-cutting, Electro-stunning,
followed by gill-cutting, Brain destruction by a pin-bolt machine, followed
by gill-cutting, and Direct gill-cutting. Sedation by CO2 or direct
gill-cutting are the most commonly used methods in the aquaculture industry,
but recently the interests in alternative methods have evolved, and commercial
use of electro-stunning and various types of brain destruction techniques are
in development. We also did a simple trial on using laughing gas N2O
as a sedative, but that apparently had no effect on the salmon. Major evaluation
criteria included development of rigor mortis and pH during storage on ice,
cortisol measurements as an indicator of stress during slaughter, and various
product quality measurements taken on raw fish stored four days on ice. As expected,
fish killed by the methods supposed to be most ‘brutal’, use of CO2
or direct gill-cutting, also went into rigor mortis first, and had the highest
rigor index. Similarly, they seemed to have the most rapid initial drop in pH.
Both these factors indicate that the use of these traditional killing methods
for salmon may be inferior to new methods like electro-stunning and pin-bolting.
Differences in ultimate flesh quality, measured on raw fish stored four days
on ice are, however, more difficult to find. Preliminary data analysis does
not indicate differences between killing methods on fillet colour; on the other
hand there are indications that fish bled to death after gill-cutting had softer
fillets (measured as Warner-Bratzler shear force). Further analysis and experiments
will go into more detail in evaluating salmon quality as a function of killing
method.
Descriptors: fish culture,
seafood, quality control, slaughter, heading, Salmo salar
ASFA; Copyright © 2003, FAO
Robb DHF, Kestin SC (2002) Methods used to kill fish: field observations and literature reviewed. Animal Welfare. 11(3):269-282
NAL Call No. HV4701.A557
Descriptors: fishes, fish
farming, slaughter, asphyxia, stunning, carbon dioxide, evisceration, animal
welfare, food quality
Robb DF, Wotton SB, Van deVis JW
(2002) Preslaughter electrical stunning
of eels. Aquaculture Research. 33(1):37-42
NAL Call No. SH1.F8
The current procedures for slaughtering European eels
(
Descriptors: processing fishery products, aquaculture products, electricity,
harvesting,
ASFA; Copyright © 2003, FAO
Robb D (1997) Welfare
of fish at slaughter. Fish Farmer. 20(2):7-8
NAL
Call No. SH151 F57
Descriptors: aquaculture,
fish culture, stunning, slaughtering, equipment, anaesthesia, carbon dioxide,
Atlantic salmon, Oncorhynchus mykiss,
fish, quality, animal welfare, animal products, aquaculture, bony fishes, diadromous
fishes, fishery products, oxides, salmon, salmonoidei
Schulz D (1978)
Zum tierschutzgerechten Betauben und
Toten von Fischen. [Humane stunning and killing of fish.] Du und das Tier. 8(1):31-33 (In German)
Descriptors: ammonia, electricity, anaesthetics, slaughter, animal
welfare, fishes
Southgate P, Wall T (2001) Welfare of farmed fish at slaughter. In Practice.
23 (5):277-280, 282-284
NAL Call No. SF601.I4
Descriptors: fishes, fish farming, animal welfare, slaughter,
fish, quality
Tejada M, Huidobro A, Pastor A (2001)
Slaughter Methods Affecting Adenosine
Triphosphate and Derivatives in Chilled Stored Gilthead Seabream (Sparus auratus). (Eds:) Kestin SC,
Warriss PD. Farmed Fish Quality. Osney Mead Oxford OX2 0EL UK.
NAL Call No. SH151 F37 2001
Animal welfare is becoming an increasingly important
part of consumer perception of quality; however, different fish slaughter procedures
can affect the final quality of the fish. Given the diversity of slaughtering
methods used in farmed fish, it is essential to assess how these methods affect
fish quality during chilled storage. Breakdown of adenosine-5'-triphosphate
(ATP) and derivatives and the ratio between them (as K value) are early indicators
of changes in post-mortem fish; they are widely used to set safe consumption
limits for raw fish and as indices of freshness of chilled fish or raw material
for gels. Our aim was to determine whether gutting immediately after death and
different methods of slaughter alter the evolution of these compounds or their
ratio during chilled storage in gilthead seabream (Sparus auratus) killed by immersion in
ice-water slurry, asphyxia in air, anaesthesia (AQUI-S™) followed by a blow
on the head, and just a blow on the head. The fish was stored with ice flakes
whole (w) or gutted (g) for a maximum time of 29 days. Forty kg (approximately
130 fish/lot) was used for each slaughter method and post-mortem treatment.
In all lots ATP rapidly degraded to inosine monophosphate (IMP) during chilling
storage, leaving no appreciable amounts of adenosine-5'-diphosphate (ADP) or
adenosine-5'-monophosphate (AMP). Dephosphorylation of IMP was slow and progressive.
Inosine (Ino) and hypoxanthine (Hx) increased gradually over storage in all
lots with no significant differences (p < 0.05), but Ino tended to accumulate
and Hx tended to stabilize by the end of storage. The molar ratio Hx : Ino was
< 5:1 throughout the period, and therefore this species was classified as
intermediate. None of the lots attained K values > 20% before seven days
in chilled storage, which means that sashimi grade (raw fish) for this species
was longer than for other commercial species. Maximum K values were established
at 50-60% at the end of the storage period, well past the sensory limit, and
around 35% (w) and 25% (g) of lots when the sensory evaluation was still within
the limits.
Descriptors: fish culture,
seafood, quality control, chilled products, slaughter, ATP, fish storage, Sparus aurata
ASFA; Copyright © 2003, FAO
van de Vis JW, Oehlenschlaeger J,
Kuhlmann H, Muenkner W, Robb DHF, Schelvis Smit AAM (2001) Effect of the commercial and experimental slaughter of eels (Anguilla anguilla L.) on quality and welfare.
(Eds:) Kestin SC, Warriss PD. Farmed
Fish Quality. Osney Mead Oxford OX2 0EL UK. Blackwell Science
Ltd. pp. 234-248
NAL Call No. SH151 F37 2001
In fish the welfare ante-mortem and the quality of the
flesh post-mortem can be adversely affected by farming and harvest conditions.
Farming conditions comprise, amongst others, water quality and stocking density.
Harvest consists of crowding, catching, transport, lairage and slaughter, and
is one of the most intense stressors in fish farming (Thomas et al. 1999). There
are similarities in anatomy, (neuro) physiology and behaviour between fish,
mammals and birds (Kestin 1994; FAWC 1996; Wendelaar Bonga 1997; Wiepkema 1997).
Therefore, it is likely that the welfare of fish can potentially be similarly
adversely affected by husbandry and harvesting conditions. In red and white
meat animals handling and slaughter procedures may have profound effects on
the course of chemical changes post-mortem and consequently on the quality of
the fresh and processed meat. There is some evidence that in fish a similar
relationship exists between harvest procedures and aspects of quality such as
water holding capacity, texture and keeping quality (Azam et al. 1989; Iwamoto
et al. 1990; Proctor et al. 1992a,b; Lowe et al. 1993; Kals et al. 1995; Templeton
1996; Marx et al. 1997; Sigholt et al. 1997; Thomas et al. 1999). However, not
all researchers have observed effects on sensory parameters attributable to
harvest methods used (see Chapter 20 by Dave Robb). Nevertheless, it is known
that both handling and slaughter methods used may affect post-mortem biochemical.
Descriptors: fish culture,
seafood, quality control, processing fishery products, heading, slaughter, Anguilla anguilla
ASFA; Copyright © 2003, FAO
Wall AJ (2001) Ethical Considerations in the Handling and
Slaughter of Farmed Fish. (Eds:) Kestin SC, Warriss PD. Farmed Fish Quality. Osney Mead Oxford OX2 0EL UK. Blackwell Science
Ltd. pp. 108-115
NAL Call No. SH151 F37 2001
This chapter will discuss preslaughter
management practices and slaughter methods, and how these might influence both
the welfare of the fish and the quality of the final product. Generally speaking
there is no conflict between the welfare of the fish and quality. Good welfare
and good quality go hand in hand.
Descriptors: fish culture, seafood, quality control, fish
handling, slaughter, processing, fishery
products
ASFA; Copyright © 2003, FAO
Wormuth HJ (1987) Das
betaeubungslose Schlachten (Schaechten) aus neuer tierschutzrechtlicher Sicht.
[Slaughtering according to Jewish rites in the view of the new animal welfare
act.] Deutsche Tieraerztliche Wochenschrift. 94(2):107-109. (In German)
NAL Call No. 41.8 D482
Descriptors: domestic animals, slaughtering, animal welfare, laws,
stunning, kosher slaughter, animal health, animals, central europe, europe,
fishing methods, fishing operations, harvesting, legislation, methods, processing,
slaughtering
Wormuth HJ (1986) Das
betaeubungslose Schlachten (Schaechten) aus neuer tierschutzrechtlicher Sicht.
[Slaughtering without stunning (kosher butchering) from the point of view of
the law of animal welfare.] Rundschau
fuer Fleischuntersuchung und Lebensmittelueberwachung. 38(11):224-225. (In German). ISSN: 0178-2010
Descriptors: domestic animals,
slaughtering, animal welfare, laws, stunning, animal health, animals, fishing
methods, fishing operations, harvesting, legislation, methods, processing, slaughtering
Aspects of Animal Welfare and Aquaculture - A Compendium of Selected Literature by
Richard D. Moccia and Kristopher P. Chandroo; Aquaculture Centre,
http://www.aps.uoguelph.ca/~aquacentre/aec/publications/welfare-bib.html
Harvest Hyperactivity and Post-Mortem Change in Tuna
Southern Bluefin Tuna Aquaculture Subprogram Newsletter, June 2000
http://www.sardi.sa.gov.au/pages/aquatics/aqua/other/sbt_june_2000.html
Processing and Marketing Aquacultured Fish
Joel M. Regenstein
Northwest
Rested Harvesting Using AQUI-S
AQUI-S New Zeland, LTD.
http://www.aqui-s.com/Default.aspx?page=1461
Return to: Top of Document
Bohl M (1978) Zur tierschutzgerechten Halterung
von Fischen.[Humane holding of fish]. Du und das Tier. 8(1):26-28 (In German)
Descriptors: stress, animal feeding, conditioning, water, fish farming,
animal welfare
Bowszys J, Kupren B (1986) Badania wstepne nad przystosowaniem podnosnika
hydropneumatycznego do transportu ryb. [Preliminary studies on adoption of a
hydropneumatic elevator for fish transport.] Acta Academiae, Agriculturae ac Technicae Olstenensis,
Aedificatio et Mechanica. 15:65-78 (In Polish with English and Russian summaries)
No mechanical injuries to the fish resulted. Oxygen levels
in the water remained within accepted tolerances.
Descriptors: aquaculture, elevators, animal welfare
Copyright © 2003, CAB International.
Collins C (1990) Live-hauling warmwater fish. Aquaculture Magazine. 16(4):70-76
NAL Call No. SH1 C65
Descriptors: animal welfare, water, oxygen, ammonia, antiinfective
agents, antibiotics, anaesthetics, transport of animals, fishes, aquatic animals
Forsberg JA, Barton BA, Summerfelt
RC (1999) Effects of ram-air ventilation during transportation on water quality
and physiology of walleye fingerlings. Stress in fish. pp. 31-36
The Iowa Department of Natural Resources
(IDNR) maintains walleye (Stizostedion
vitreum) populations in most
Descriptors: fish physiology, biological stress, ventilation,
carbon dioxide, oxygen, water quality,
environmental effects, Stizostedion vitreum
ASFA; Copyright © 2003, FAO
Laboratory Animal Breeders Association
of Great Britain Limited (LABA) and Laboratory Animal Science Association (LASA).
(1993) Guidelines for the care of laboratory
animals in transit. Laboratory Animals (
NAL Call No. QL55 A1L3
Descriptors: animals, laboratory, transportation, animal
feed, animal welfare, cats, dogs, guinea pigs, hamsters, housing, animal, laboratory
animal science, mice, primates, rats, fish
Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries
and Food, Scottish Office Agriculture, Environment and Fisheries Department,
Welsh Office Agriculture Department (1997) Draft Guidance on the Welfare of Animals (Transport)
Order 1997.
NAL Call No. KD3424.A33 1997
Descriptors: animals, animal welfare,
fish, transport
Muzinic R (1970) On the use of
anaesthetics in the transportation of sardines. Studies
and Reviews of the General Fisheries Council of the
The rate of mortality of non-selected sardines, exposed
to 1:150 000 conc of tricaine methane sulfonate in open-system experiments increased
rapidly and after 2 hr, by far exceeded 50 per cent. The mortality rate of the
fish slowed down considerably when the sardines were transferred to a fresh
anaesthetic solution at 30 min intervals using a conc of 1:150 000 tricaine
methane sulfonate or compressed air when the temps were 20.8° and 21.7°C; transferring
the sardines had the same effect on their mortality using chloral hydrate at
both 1:1000 and 1:3 000 concs and the effect was even more notable at the latter
concs. Similar procedure may be applied in transporting sardines, especially
from distant localities for tagging and other experimental work. It is possible
that some changes in the composition of the anaesthetic solution during the
initial phase of transportation may be useful. With changes in the anaesthetic
solution being made at 30-min intervals, lower concs of chloral hydrate were
more advantageous. In standard anaesthesia experiments however, this was not
so. In standard anaesthesia experiments with chloral hydrate, a rapid increase
in mortality occurred at a decline of the O2 conc to a point below
2 cc/1. In open system standard anaesthesia experiments using 1:150 000
tricaine methane sulfonate conc, the last sardine died at a temp ranging from
20.3° to 22.8°C and at a mean final O2 value of 0.56 ± 0.46 cc/1.
Chloral hydrate at 1:3 000 and 1:5 000 concs (and perhaps even lower ones) may
replace tricaine methane sulfonate in transporting the sardines. The delicate
state of the fish was shown by a marked variability of the mortality course
within all the series of anaesthesia experiments and by a rather high mean final
oxygen value and its great variation.
Descriptors: anaesthetics, tricane methane sulfonate, sardines,
titration experiment, chloral hydrate, temperature, oxygen
ASFA; Copyright © 2003, FAO
Nowak D (1989) Tierschutzrelevante Aspekte bei Halterung,
Verkauf und Totung von Susswasserspeisefischen. [Welfare aspects of the holding,
selling and killing of freshwater fishes for food.] Rundschau fur Fleischhygiene und Lebensmitteluberwachung
41(7):139-140
(In German)
Descriptors: animal welfare, aquaculture, fish farming
Schulz D (1974) Tierschutz und Halterung sowie Transport von
Fischen. [Animal welfare, containers and transport of fish.] Berliner
und Munchener Tierarztliche Wochenschrift. 87(18):359-362
(In German with English summary)
NAL Call No. 41.8
B45
Present methods of holding and transporting fish are
discussed, the legal requirements mentioned, and methods suggested which satisfy
the legal and humane conditions.
Descriptors: legislation, transport of animals, transport, animal
welfare, fishes
Copyright © 2003, CAB International.
Stede M (1978) Zur tierschutzgerechten Halterung von Fischen.
[Humane holding of fish.] Du und das
Tier. 8(1):29 (In German)
Descriptors: stress, water, environmental temperature, fish farming,
animal welfare
Varadi L, Hegyi A, Hopp
B (2000) Narcotics in the fish transportation
[Narkotikumok alkalmazasa a halszallitasban]. Halaszat.
93(1):44-48
NAL Call
No. 414.8 H12
Nowadays, by the spreading of the intensive
way of fish breeding the individual and collective treatment of these animals
has gained even more importance. It appears also in propagation, breeding technologies
and health care as well as in transportation. Because of the basic anatomical
and physiological makings of fish tasks can hardly be done when awake without
threathening the health of life of these animals. This more intensive way of
fish production in ponds has sharply increased the demand for more stocks of
fish. In many cases the weakest point in fish breeding technologies is transportation.
Descriptors: fishes, transport of animals, animal welfare,
anaesthetics, drugs, neurotropic drug, transport
Vollmann-Schipper F (1978) Zum tierschutzgerechten Transport von Fischen.
[Humane transport of live fish.] Du und das Tier. 8(1):30-31 (In German)
Descriptors: stress, containers, water, transport of animals, animal
welfare, fishes
Yin Bangzhong, Liu Qi, Liang Mengqing,
Jiang Yaosen (1995) On transportation of
live sea fish.
The common method for transportation of live animal is aeration method, anaesthesia
method and low temperature method. But using non-water lowering temperature
to keep fish alive for transportation has many advantages such as big load amount,
no contamination and high quality, etc. It is a developing tendency to use this
method for transportation of live sea fish.
Descriptors: live storage, storage conditions, fish storage,
cold storage, transportation
ASFA; Copyright © 2003, FAO
Zhang Xiaolan, Lin Hong, Lou Weifeng,
Xue Changhu (1993) Studies on comprehensively raising the survival rate in
the transport of the live fish.
In order to raise the survival rate in the transport of the live fish a positive
crossing experiment (L9(34) was
made to transport the live Jian-carp first immersed in water with the concentration
of 100 x 10-6 carbonic acid and later taken out to be put into the
closing container filled with water containing different concentrations of the
selected NaCl, H2O2 and Terramycin. The result showed
that in seven groups the survival rate of Jian-carp was 80% on an average, and
only the survival rate of the sceond group reached 100% in the water in proportion
of 0.2% NaCl, 170ml H2O2 and 20 x 10-6 Terramycin.
The positive relativation appeared apparently between the dissolved oxygen and
the survival rate; although the oxygen resourse, the variety of anaesthetic
and medicine could effected more and less on the survival rate, yet there was
no marked difference between the factors and the concentrations effected on
the survival rate.
Descriptors: transportation, fish handling, survival, live
storage
ASFA; Copyright © 2003, FAO
Aspects of Animal Welfare and Aquaculture - A Compendium of Selected Literature by
Richard D. Moccia and Kristopher P. Chandroo; Aquaculture Centre,
http://www.aps.uoguelph.ca/~aquacentre/aec/publications/welfare-bib.html
Capturing, Handling, Transporting, Injecting and Holding
Broodfish for Induced Spawning
RW Rottman, JV Shierman, FA Chapman
Southern
http://govdocs.aquake.org/cgi/reprint/2003/724/7240040.pdf
Collecting Rainbowfishes
http://members.optusnet.com.au/aquatichabitats/Collect.htm
Marketing and Shipping Live Aquatic Products
http://www.nraes.org/publications/nraes107.html
Transportation of Warmwater Fish: Equipment and Guidelines
GL Jensen
Southern
http://www.ca.uky.edu/wkrec/390fs.PDF
Transport of Fish and Crustaceans in Sealed Containers
S.K. Johnson, 1988. Transport of Fish and Crustaceans in Sealed Containers. Inland Aquaculture Handbook. Texas Aquaculture Association, College Station, TX. A1504-A1509.
NAL Call No. 414.9 AM3
We examined the effects of surgically and gastrically implanted radio transmitters
(representing 2.3-5.5% of body weight) on the growth and feeding behavior of
192 juvenile chinook salmon Oncorhynchus
tshawytscha (114-159 mm in fork length). Throughout the 54-d study, the
48 fish with transmitters in their stomachs (gastric fish) consistently grew
more slowly than fish with surgically implanted transmitters (surgery fish),
fish with surgery but no implanted transmitter (sham-surgery fish), or fish
exposed only to handling (control fish). Growth rates of surgery fish were also
slightly impaired at day 21, but by day 54 they were growing at rates comparable
with those of control fish. Despite differences in growth, overall health was
similar among all test fish. However, movement of the transmitter antenna caused
abrasions at the corner of the mouth in all gastric fish, whereas only 22% of
the surgery fish had inflammation around the antenna exit wound. Feeding activity
was similar among groups, but gastric fish exhibited a coughing behavior and
appeared to have difficulty retaining swallowed food. Because growth and feeding
behavior were less affected by the presence of surgically implanted transmitters
than by gastric implants, we recommend surgically implanting transmitters for
biotelemetry studies of juvenile chinook salmon between 114 and 159 mm fork length.
Descriptors: tagging, feeding behaviour, mortality causes,
telemetry, growth, feeding behavior, marking and tracking techniques, surgery, Oncorhynchus tshawytscha, growth, Oncorhynchus,
Chinook salmon
ASFA; Copyright © 2003, FAO
Benoit E, Laurent D, Mattei C, Legrand
AM, Molgo J (2000) Reversal of Pacific ciguatoxin-1B effects on myelinated
axons by agents used in ciguatera treatment. First Meeting on Ichtyology in
Ciguatera fish poisoning is a distinctive form of ichthyosarcotoxism characterised
mainly by gastrointestinal and neurological disturbances. The ciguatoxins, responsible
for this poisoning, are complex polyethers produced by toxic strains of the
dinoflagellate Gambierdiscus toxicus. These toxins are increased to dangerous
levels for man during their transmission through herbivorous and carnivorous
fish, various species being contaminated. The known molecular target of ciguatoxins
is the voltagegated Na+ channel. During the action of these toxins, the permanent
opening of channels, at the resting membrane potential, produces a continuons
entry of Na+ ions in excitable tells causing a marked increase in membrane excitability
and in cellular volume. To precise the neurocellular bases of the efficacy of
some agents used in clinical and traditional treatments of ciguatera, their
effects were studied on frog myelinated axons exposed to Pacific ciguatoxin-1B
(CTX-1B). During the action of this toxin, the increase in axonal volume and
membrane excitability was reversed by lidocaine (a local anaesthetic), by CaCl2
and by hyperosmotic external solutions (containing D-mannitol, sucrose or tetramethylammonium
chloride). The CTX-1B-induced hyperexcitability of the membrane was also reversed
by extracts of Argusia argentea leaves or Davallia solida rhizomes, used traditionally
in New-Caledonia. It is concluded that the various agents studied are able to
counteract the neurocellular effects of CTX-1B in myelinated axons. These results
are of particular interest since they provide a scientific basis to understand
the beneficial action of therapeutic agents used in the treatment of ciguatera
fish poisoning.
Original Abstract: La ciguatera est une forme
particuliere d'ichtyosarcotoxisme principalement caracterisee par des troubles
gastro-intestinaux et neurologiques. Ce sont les ciguatoxines, polyethers complexes
produits par des varietes toxiques du dinoflagelle Gambierdiscus toxicus, qui
en sont responsables en se concentrant pour atteindre des doses dangereuses
pour l'homme lors de leur transfert dans de nombreuses especes de poissons herbivores
et carnivores. La cible moleculaire connue des ciguatoxines est le canal Na+
sensible au potentiel de membrane. Durant l'action de ces toxines, l'ouverture
permanente des canaux au potentiel de repos de la membrane, produit une entree
continue d'ions Na+ dans les cellules excitables ce qui augmente notablement
l'excitabilite membranaire et le volume cellulaire. Dans le but de preciser
les bases neurocellulaires de l'efficacite.de certains agents utilises dans
le traitement clinique et traditionnel de la ciguatera, leurs effets ont ete
etudies sur des axones myelinises de grenouille prealablement soumis a l'action
de la ciguatoxine-1B du Pacifique (CTX-1B). L'augmentation du volume axonal
et de l'excitabilite de la membrane, produite par cette toxine, a ete neutralisee
par la lidocaine (anesthesique local), le CaCl2, et les milieux extracellulaires
hyperosmotiques contenant du D mannitol, du saccharose ou du chlorure de tetramethylammonium.L'hyperexcitabilite
membranaire, produite par la CTX-1B, a egalement ete supprimee par les extraits
de feuilles d'Argusia argentea ou de rhizomes de Davallia solida, utilises dans
la medecine traditionnelle en Nouvelle Caledonie. En conclusion, les divers
agents etudies sont capables de neutraliser les effets neurocellulaires de la
CTX-1B au niveau des axones myelinises. Ces resultats sont particulierement
interessants puisqu'ils apportent une base scientifique necessaire a la comprehension
de l'action benefique des agents therapeutiques utilises de maniere encore empirique
dans le traitement de l'ichtyosarcotoxisme de type ciguatera.
Descriptors: ciguatoxin, fish poisoning, ions, therapy
ASFA; Copyright © 2003, FAO
Benzer TI, Raftery MA (1972) Partial
characterization of a tetrodotoxin-binding component from nerve membrane.
Proceedings of the National
NAL Call No. 500 N21P
Tecrodotoxin from Japanese puffer fish has been labeled with tritium and purified
from the crude mixture obtained. The interaction between the purified [3H]tetrodotoxin
and membrane suspensions from the olfactory nerve of long-nosed garfish has
been investigated by equilibrium dialysis. Tetrodotoxin binds to membrane suspensions
with a dissociation constant KD=8.3nM. The nerve preparation binds
42 pmol of [3H]tetrodotoxin/g of wet tissue
at saturating toxin concentrations. With various hydrolic enzymes, the binding
component is shown to be a protein embedded in a phospholipid environment. The
binding is inhibited below pH 4.0 and is not stable towards heat. Tetrodotoxin
binding is not inhibited by the local anesthetic, procaine.
Descriptors: puffer fish, tecrodotoxin, nerve, membrane,
fish, phospholipic environment
ASFA; Copyright © 2003, FAO
Bidgood BF (1980) Field surgical
procedure for implantation of radio tags in fish. Fisheries Research
Report, Fish and Wildlife Division.
(
Equipment and methods employed in surgically implanting radio tags in fish
in the field are described. Anesthetic and recovery procedures that reduce or
eliminate shock and stress are presented. Field and laboratory applications
of the procedure are documented.
Descriptors: tagging, sonic tags, Pisces, Canada, Alberta,
methodology, freshwater fish, electronic equipment, fatigue (biological), migrations
ASFA; Copyright © 2003, FAO
Blankenship HL, Leber KM (1995) A
responsible approach to marine stock enhancement. Uses and Effects of
Cultured Fishes in Aquatic Ecosystems., American Fisheries Society, Bethesda,
MD (USA), 15:167-179
NAL Call No. SH3 A5
Declining marine fish populations worldwide have rekindled
an interest in marine fish enhancement. Recent technological advances in fish
tagging and marine fish culture provide a basis for successful hatchery-based
marine enhancement. To ensure success and avoid repeating mistakes, we must
take a responsible approach to developing, evaluating, and managing marine stock
enhancement programs. A responsible-approach concept with several key components
is described. Each component is considered essential to control and optimize
enhancement. The components include the need to (1) prioritize and select target
species for enhancement; (2) develop a species management plan that identifies
harvest opportunity, stock rebuilding goals, and genetic objectives; (3) define
quantitative measures of success; (4) use genetic resource management to avoid
deleterious genetic effects; (5) use disease and health management; (6) consider
ecological, biological, and life-history patterns when forming enhancement objectives
and tactics; (7) identify released hatchery fish and assess stocking effects;
(8) use an empirical process for defining optimum release strategies; (9) identify
economic and policy guidelines; and (10) use adaptive management. Developing
case studies with Atlantic cod Gadus morhua,
red drum Sciaenops ocellatus, striped
Mugil cephalus, and white seabass
Atractoscion nobilis are used to verify
that the responsible approach to marine stock enhancement is practical and can
work.
Descriptors: marine fish, fishery development, cultured organisms,
stock assessment, resource management, population genetics, stocking density,
Gadus morhua, Sciaenops ocellatus, Mugil
cephalus, Atractoscion nobilis, Gadidae, Mugilidae, Sciaenidae, USA coasts
ASFA; Copyright © 2003, FAO
Brennan NP, DeBruler R, Blankenship
HL, Leber KM (2001) Coded-wire tag and visible implant elastomer tag retention
in juvenile red snapper Lutjanus campechanus.
Aquaculture 2001: Book of Abstracts. p. 77
As part of the Gulf of Mexico Marine Stock Enhancement Program, a series of
tag retention experiments on juvenile red snapper, Lutjanus campechanus, reared
at the Gulf Coast Research Laboratory in Ocean Springs, MS were initiated to
adapt current tagging technology to red snapper stock enhancement research.
Coded-wire tags (CWT) and internal visible implant elastomers (VIE) (NMT,
Descriptors: marine aquaculture, fish culture, tags, tagging,
juveniles, stocking (organisms), stock identification, hatcheries, aquaculture
techniques, marine fish, Lutjanus campechanus,
ASW, Mexico Gulf, tag retention, visual implant elastomers, red snapper
ASFA; Copyright © 2003, FAO
Bruyndoncx L, Knaepkens G, Meeus
W, Bervoets L, Eens M (2002) The evaluation of passive integrated transponder
(PIT) tags and visible implant elastomer (VIE) marks as new marking techniques
for the bullhead. Journal of Fish Biology. 60(1):260-26
NAL Call No. QL614 J68
To test the reliability of PIT tags and VIE marks as new marking techniques
for the bullhead Cottus gobio, different
tagging treatments were assayed. The relatively high recapture rates suggest
the applicability of both marking techniques for this small benthic fish species.
Copyright 2002 The Fisheries Society of the British Isles
Descriptors: tracking, local movements, freshwater fish,
tagging, marking and tracking techniques, Cottus
gobio, bullhead
ASFA; Copyright © 2003, FAO
Close
TL, Jones TS (2002) Detection of visible implant elastomer in fingerling
and yearling rainbow trout. North American Journal of Fisheries Management.
22(3):961-964
NAL Call No. SH219.N66
Visible implant elastomer (VIE) was evaluated for marking yearling rainbow trout
Oncorhynchus mykiss. The rate of tag
detection after the yearlings had been at large for 35 months was also compared
with the detection rate found in a subsequent year-class that had been marked
as fingerlings and had been at large for 29 months. Fish were marked in the
postocular adipose eyelid tissue and on the ventral surface of the lower jaw
and examined in the dark under ultraviolet light. Detection rates for both year-classes
ranged from 29% to 33%, based on the proportion of fish with two detectable
marks. Because the marks were not easily recognized, we believe the detection
rates were overestimated. We conclude that detection of VIE at the sites we
chose was problematic for the strain of rainbow trout we marked. More favorable
long-term detection rates in other species suggest that poor detection rates
may be unique to heavily pigmented strains of rainbow trout.
Descriptors: marking, tracking, tagging, freshwater fish,
fishery management, Oncorhynchus mykiss,
rainbow trout
ASFA; Copyright © 2003, FAO
Knights BC, Lasee BA (1996) Effects
of implanted transmitters on adult bluegills at two temperatures. Transactions
of the American Fisheries Society. 125(3):440-449
NAL Call No. 414.9 AM3
Laterally compressed panfishes are small and have limited intraperitoneal space;
thus, they may suffer adversely from surgically implanted transmitters even
if the transmitter meets the generally recommended ratio of transmitter weight
to fish weight of 2%. We studied the effects of intraperitoneal transmitters
(2.81 g) on survival, growth, healing, and health of bluegills Lepomis macrochirus (mean weight 133 g)
held for 8 weeks at 6°C and 20°C. Radio-tagged bluegills at 20°C had a mortality
rate of 10% and tag loss rate of 15%. At 6°C, bluegills had no mortality or
tag loss. Radio-tagged and reference fish fed in both 20°C raceways; however,
a few reference fish appeared dominant at feeding time. This dominance by a
few reference fish was also indicated by a large weight gain for three reference
fish in each 20°C raceway. At 6°C, neither reference fish nor radio-tagged fish
fed activity. Radio-tagged fish held at 20°C exhibited pelvic fin erosion, erythema
and necrosis at the antenna exit and at suture insertions, and lost or loose
sutures, effects not observed in other test fishes. Examination of fish held
at 20°C also showed enclosure of the transmitters in a fibrous capsule and adhesion
of visceral organs. Epithelialization over the incision occurred in radio-tagged
bluegills at both temperatures, but there was little further healing at 6°C.
At 20°C, tissue responses included chronic inflammation and dermal granulation.
Radio-tagged fish did not appear to be more susceptible than reference fish
to bacterial infection. Mortality, adverse morphological effects, altered behavior,
and limited healing in bluegills suggest that implanted transmitters impaired
their health. Thus, movement and habitat use data collected by telemetry for
this species and perhaps for other panfishes should be interpreted with caution.
Descriptors: tagging mortality, tags, Lepomis macrochirus, sonic tags, biotelemetry, biological stress,
mortality, stress
ASFA; Copyright © 2003, FAO
Mahapatra KD, Gjerde B, Reddy PVG,
Sahoo M, Jana RK, Saha JN, Rye M (2001) Tagging: on the use of passive integrated
transponder (PIT) tags for the identification of fish. Aquaculture Research. 32(1):47-50
NAL Call No. SH1 F8
To determine the efficacy of passive integrated transponder (PIT) tags for marking
rohu Labeo rohita (Ham.) in the selective
breeding programme, a series of experiments has been carried out at the Central
Institute of Freshwater Aquaculture (CIFA) under the Indo-Norwegian project
of ‘Selective breeding of rohu’. Six groups of rohu fingerlings with weight
ranging from 2 g to 20 g were tagged with PIT tags to determine a suitable size
range for tagging. Fingerlings weighing 8-15 g were found to be quite suitable
for tagging with a PIT tag. Recovery of the PIT tag depends upon the survival
of tagged fish under field conditions. Rejection of the PIT tag by rohu was
observed to be only 0.05%. Through effective management practice, the survival
of tagged fish increased up to 95%, and thus tag loss was minimized.
Descriptors: tagging, identification, acoustic transponders,
induced breeding, fish culture, fishery management, Labeo rohita
ASFA; Copyright © 2003, FAO
Mangan BP (1998) Long-term retention
of a radio transmitter by a muskellunge. Journal of Freshwater Ecology.
13(4):485-487
NAL Call No. QH541.5.F7J68
The use of surgically implanted radio transmitters in fish is widespread. There
are, however, some questions concerning retention time of transmitters and effects
on fish health. The author serendipitously recovered a large adult muskellunge
implanted with a radio transmitter for 13 years. Although a large fibrous mass
was associated with the transmitter, this ripe female otherwise appeared to
be disease-free.
Descriptors: tags, tagging mortality, biotelemetry, tracking,
radio telemetry, Esox masquinongy
ASFA; Copyright © 2003, FAO
Martin SW, Long JA, Pearsons TN (1995)
Comparison of survival, gonad development, and growth between rainbow trout
with and without surgically implanted dummy radio transmitters. North
American Journal of Fisheries Management. 15(2):494-498
NAL Call No. SH219.N66
The use of radio telemetry to determine fish movement patterns associated with
spawning has proliferated in recent years. However, little is known about the
effect of surgically implanted radio transmitters on spawning behavior or gonad
development of fish collected near the time of spawning. We compared survival,
gonad development, and growth between wild rainbow trout Oncorhynchus mykiss with and without dummy radio transmitters that
were surgically implanted prior to the fish's spawning period. Wild rainbow
trout (mean fork length, 351 mm) were collected from the
Descriptors: Oncorhynchus
mykiss, tagging mortality, biological development, growth, biotelemetry,
ASFA; Copyright © 2003, FAO
Olsen RE, Henderson RJ (1997) Muscle
fatty acid composition and oxidative stress indices of Arctic charr, Salvelinus alpinus (L.), in relation to
dietary polyunsaturated fatty acid levels and temperature. Aquaculture
Nutrition. 3(4):227-238
NAL Call No. SH156.A658
The influence of feeding high levels of polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFA) on
muscle fatty acid composition and indices of oxidative damage was examined in
Arctic charr, Salvelinus alpinus (L.).
All diets contained 100 g/kg lipid of dry weight. Two diets contained marine
fish oils giving a PUFA level of 250 g/kg and 500 g/kg of lipid. The remaining
two diets contained vegetable oils high in either 18:2n-6 or 18:3n-3, giving
a PUFA level of more than 500 g/kg of dietary lipid. The charr were maintained
at 8°C until their weight doubled, and were then transferred to 0.8°C for 30
days. Growth was similar in all groups. The fatty acid compositions of muscle
were influenced by dietary PUFA but were less diverse than those of the diets.
The overall pattern of fatty acid compositions indicated preferential desaturation
and elongation of n-3 PUFA coupled with selective oxidation of 18:2n-6. Total
n-3 PUFA content in TAG was always lowered compared with the diet, suggesting
a specific mechanism for the removal of these fatty acids. Subjecting the fish
to low temperature increased PUFA content in muscle of charr fed the 250 g/kg
marine n-3 PUFA diet, but had no effect on the other treatments. For fish at
8°C, no significant differences were found between groups in terms of haematocrit,
plasma alanine aminotransferase (ALAT), and plasma and muscle thiobarbituric
acid reactive substances (TBARS), although there was a tendency towards increased
levels of TBARS in the group receiving 500 g/kg marine n-3 PUFA of lipid. Subjecting
the muscle to forced oxidative conditions resulted in increases in TBARS in
all groups, particularly those fed 500 g/kg marine n-3 PUFA. Lowering the environmental
temperature corresponded with a further increase in the plasma ALAT and muscle
TBARS in this group. It is concluded that feeding diets containing high levels
of long-chain n-3 PUFA may be detrimental to the fish's health and flesh quality,
particularly at low environmental temperatures.
Descriptors: muscles, fatty acids, biochemical composition,
food conversion, nutritional requirements, temperature effects, biological stress,
Salvelinus alpinus, diets, growth,
Arctic char
ASFA;
Copyright © 2003, FAO
Petry H (1976) Experiments for
the registration of fish toxicants. The Influence of Environmental Factors
upon the Health of Fishes. Die Einwirkung von Umweltfaktoren auf die Gesunderhaltung
des Fisches. No. 2. (In German with English summary)
A quantified registration of spontaneous activity of animals can be
carried out easily and in a reliable way using the principle of magnetic induction.
To study the practicability of this method for continuous control of waters
using test fish as indicators, changes of spontaneous activity of magnet marked
trouts exposed to detergents have been detected by induced voltages.
Descriptors: bioassays, methodology, tagging, magnetism,
Oncorhynchus mykiss, Pisces
ASFA; Copyright © 2003, FAO
Pollard MJ, Kingsford MJ,
NAL Call No. 157.5 B87
The aim of this project was to investigate the use of strontium as a chemical
tag in the dorsal spines of the marine teleost Pagrus auratus that would allow the mass tagging of juvenile fish.
Previous studies in which the incorporation of strontium has been experimentally
manipulated for the purposes of marking have generally concentrated on freshwater
and anadromous species. This is the first study to investigate the tagging of
spines with strontium, the removal of which is non-destructive. Inductively
coupled plasmamass spectrometry (ICP-MS) was used to measure isotopic concentrations.
The dorsal spines of juvenile P. auratus that had been immersed in salt
water containing 0.125 g/L SrCl2 x 6H2O (5x ambient strontium)
and 0.250 g/L (10x ambient) for five days incorporated 86Sr at levels
greater than those in control fish. The strontium signal was persistent in spines
for at least 36 days and showed no sign of decay during the experiment. No effects
of the treatments on fish health or growth were detected. Short-term immersion
experiments (6 hours to 5 days) indicated that treatments of 10x ambient or
greater for 4-5 days were required to tag fish reliably with strontium. Natural
levels of strontium in the spines of juveniles varied among locations separated
by tens of kilometres along the coast of
Descriptors: tagging, strontium, dorsal fins, marking, fins,
Pagrus auratus, PSE,
ASFA; Copyright © 2003, FAO
Schweigert J, Flostrand L, Slotte
A, Tallman D (date not provided) Application of coded wire tagging technology
in Pacific herring to investigate stock structure and migration. International
Council for the Exploration of the Sea, Palaegade 2-4 DK-1261 Copenhagen Denmark..
Tagging of Pacific herring in British Columbia to understand stock structure
and mixing rates of populations using internal metal tags and external Floy
tags has a long history dating to the mid-1930s. Unfortunately, uncertainty
in some tag recovery locations and low rates of tag return limited the utility
of these studies. In 1999, a new tagging program was initiated employing coded
wire microtags to mark Pacific herring on the spawning grounds to monitor the
movement and mixture of fish interannually. Tank experiments indicated high
rates of survival and low tag shedding rates, and field trials indicated the
feasibility of cost effective application of large numbers of tags during the
short spawning season (250,000 tags applied over 28 days). Methodologies for
capturing, holding, tagging, and releasing tagged herring were developed. Tank
experiments also investigated the effects of the location of tag insertion and
anaesthetic on short-term (3 months) survival and tag retention. Tag detection
tubes designed for recovery of tagged Pacific salmon were adapted to detect
and recover Pacific herring in fish plants during roe extraction processing.
Tag recovery rates of 1-2% in 2000 from the 1999 releases greatly exceeded the
returns from previous tagging programs. Tag returns indicated a high degree
of homing or fidelity to the area of release, but also produced a number of
remarkable strays. Coded wire tagging technology appears to provide a useful
tool for large-scale marking experiments on smaller pelagic species and should
have broad application for stock structure and mark-recapture studies.
Descriptors: tagging, tags, survival, fish handling, migrations,
clupeoid fisheries, stock identification, Clupea pallasi, INE, Canada, British Columbia, coded wire tags, Pacific
herring
ASFA; Copyright © 2003, FAO
Stobo WT (1972) The effect of
dart tags on yellow perch. Transactions of the American Fisheries Society.
101(2):365-366
NAL Call No. 414.9 AM3
Yellow perch carrying T-bar spaghetti tags in heavily vegetated areas showed
wounds around the point of insertion, which might cause differential mortality
in comparison with untagged fish. The retention and possible effects of the
tags are investigated. 46 perch seined from the Ottawa River were tagged with
FD-67 dart tags using Dell's method but without anaesthetic. They were then
released back into the river. In the lab 16 perch were tagged plus and minus
anaesthetic and/or alcohol treatment for the equipment. 26 specimens recaptured
form the field showed no tag loss; open wounds occurred at the point of attachment,
but without apparent infection. In the lab wounds were smaller but otherwise
similar. It was concluded that the field tagging procedure was not responsible
for the occurrence of the wounds and it is therefore satisfactory. Tag retention
is good and mortality insignificant.
Descriptors: yellow perch, FD-67, field tagging procedure
ASFA; Copyright © 2003, FAO
Thoreau X, Baras E (1997) Evaluation
of surgery procedures for implanting telemetry transmitters into the body cavity
of tilapia Oreochromis aureus.
Aquatic Living Resources/Ressources Vivantes Aquatiques.
NAL Call No. SH1.A8
Surgery procedures were used to implant telemetry transmitters into the body
cavity of adult (574 - 1033 g) tilapias Oreochromis
aureus in aquaculture tanks (4 m2,1.5
m3, 26.5 ± 0.5°C, greater than or equal to 5.0 mg O2/L)
and their effect on fish survival, growth and behaviour was evaluated. Only
one out of 35 implanted fish died. With one exception, all fish consistently
retained their transmitter until the end of the study (up to 30 months). Healing
was faster when the incision was sutured with polyamide monofilament (5-14 days)
than with other suture materials, due to tunnelling with atraumatic needles
for catgut or fouling of braided silk. In all 10 fish sacrificed after 30 and
50 days, the transmitter had become encapsulated by connective tissue. No infection
or damage to the viscera was observed. The activity of four tilapias (903-1033
g) equipped with motion sensitive transmitters was telemetered during the recovery
from anaesthesia and surgical procedures. All four fish maintained a normal
diurnal activity rhythm pattern throughout the study but had low levels of activity
during the first 12-24 h. Based on the evolution of their resting posture after
surgery, it is suggested that tilapias need 3 to 4 days to completely compensate
the negative buoyancy resulting from anaesthesia and tagging.
Descriptors: telemetry, tagging, aquaculture, tanks, warm-water
aquaculture, Oreochromis aureus, Pisces
ASFA; Copyright © 2003, FAO
Turner SE, Proctor GW, Parker RL
(1974) Rapid marking of rainbow trout. Progressive Fish Culturist.
36(3):172-174
NAL Call No. 157.5 P94
The authors describe the apparatus used when cold branding 428,895 rainbow trout
prior to release in Lake Taneycomo, Missouri. After the fish had been anaesthetised
with methypentynol they were placed against the silver brand which was cooled
by liquid N2. One marking table could brand {approx} 200 trout per
hr. Mortality was between 0.05 and 1.80% for branded trout, mostly as a result
of handling or the anaesthetic. Most marks were identifiable, even after an
increase in size from 4.0 to 24.0 in. The most legible marks were I, X and O.
Mark durability on trout >10 in total length was not judged but it is noted
that normal abrasions found on hatchery trout of this size would make it difficult
to identify brands of the size used on the 4-6 in fish.
Descriptors: marking, Oncorhynchus
mykiss
ASFA; Copyright © 2003, FAO
Chapter 7 Fish Welfare and Health in Relation to Tagging,
written by Prof. John Davenport
(group leader), Dr. Etienne Baras, Dr. Gianna Fabi, and Dr. Gisli Jonsson,
http://www.hafro.is/catag/g-reference/chapter_7.html
excerpted
from Thorsteinsson V (2002) Tagging
Methods for Stock Assessment and
Research
in Fisheries, Report of Concerted Action FAIR CT.96.1394 (CATAG).